Why Is The Temperature Of Your Shower Water Changing Suddenly And How Can You Fix It? - House Digest (2024)

Home Improvement Repairs

ad-foto/Shutterstock

ByEzekiel Maina/June 21, 2023 12:28 pm EST

Ah, the shower — that blissful oasis of relaxation and rejuvenation where we wash away the day's dirt, grime, and worries, belt out our favorite tunes without judgment, brainstorm our next big idea, or simply bask in the warmth of cascading water. But when that warm embrace suddenly becomes a freezing or scalding nightmare, it can turn your blissful retreat into a frustrating guessing game. The suspect? It could be a faulty pressure-balancing valve, an underpowered water heater, or a defective shower cartridge. As for an undersized water heater, it might be time to upgrade to a bigger model or invest in a smaller-capacity auxiliary unit. And if your pipes are too narrow or your circuit breaker keeps tripping? Professional assistance will come in handy to ensure a pleasant shower experience.

Shower water temperature problems extend beyond the unpleasant surprise, annoyance, or dampened enthusiasm. It's also a matter of safety. Sudden hot water can scald your skin, per Appliance Analysts, while cold bursts can cause you to slip or fall as you instinctively try to escape the chilly embrace. By understanding the underlying causes of water temperature swings and taking the necessary steps to address them, you can reclaim your shower as the soothing sanctuary it was meant to be.

Santiparp Wattanap*rn/Shutterstock

Let's begin with water wars. If your shower could be locked in a fierce battle for dominance with other water appliances in your home, you can expect wild rollercoaster rides in shower temperature. The other likely culprit is the pressure balancing valve. This sensitive plumbing accessory helps maintain harmony between hot and cold water, but a hot-cold dance of the shower temperature tango ensues when it falters. Next up, you could be dealing with a water heaterthat fails to meet the requirements of your shower system. But let's not forget that sediment buildup in the tank can sabotage your system's capacity and efficiency, causing similar temperature chaos.

The problem can be traced back to the very veins of your plumbing — in this case, narrow pipes that barely deliver the water necessary water volume. Imagine squeezing a watermelon through a straw; something has to give. Moving on, we encounter a circuit breaker that keeps tripping and severing power to your water heater, thanks to a faulty breaker or overloaded circuits. But what if your shower starts warm, then goes cold when other water-using appliances join the party? The shower cartridge is likely to blame. When worn out or damaged, this gadget nestled inside the shower valve just can't handle the pressure of all several appliances competing for water. The result is a shower experience that feels more like a weather roulette than a relaxing retreat.

Oasishifi/Shutterstock

Intervention by a professional plumber will suffice for a malfunctioning pressure-balancing valve. But strategically scheduling your water usage is key to achieving harmony in the battle between water-using appliances. For instance, limit washing machine or dishwasher use during shower time. Or, if your shower is thirstier for hot water than your heater can supply, it's time to up your game with a compact supplementary heater or a larger-capacity model. Alternatively, rethinking your shower type or flushing your existing water heater could do the trick.

The clear answer to undersized pipes is to upgrade the trunk or branch pipe size, which demands a major plumbing makeover to ensure compatibility. While making such an investmentcan be quite expensive, you can always envision bigger pipes for your next home. As for a perpetually overheating circuit breaker, this is no time for heroics — let a reputable electrician tackle that. At last, we arrive at the grand finale: replacing a defective shower cartridge. Begin by shutting off the water supply to the shower, then remove the knob cover, handle, escutcheon plate, and retainer clip to expose the cartridge. Afterward, extract the old cartridge using a pair of pliers, smoothly slide in the replacement, and finally, reassemble the remaining components. Good luck restoring normalcy to your shower temperatures.